Feminist Philosophers

News feminist philosophers can use

Mammograms in England and the US April 2, 2009

Filed under: ageing,aging,autonomy,medicine — annejjacobson @ 11:27 pm

A leter to the London Times has lead British medical authorities at least to plan to rewrite leaflets that give women ‘the standard advice’ about mammograms.  The letter, whose lead signer is apparently a very distinguished professor emeritus of surgery, mentions a forthcoming study that finds that “if 2,000 women are screened regularly for ten years, one will benefit from the screening, as she will avoid dying from breast cancer. At the same time, ten healthy women will, as a consequence, become “cancer patients” and will be treated unnecessarily.”  The letter also asserts that about 50% of the genuinely positive cases detected by mammograms are too slow growing to be worth treating.

This is worrying from a number of  points of view.  Mammograms are promoted much more aggressively in the US, and I don’t think I have ever heard of a positive result that led to no action (though of course I could just not be well informed). 

The second link above will take you to a fairly detailed report on the story.

The idea of a slow-growing tumor is sometimes cited in prostate cases, but  it is worth asking whether it is something women might be told in cases of breast cancer.

 

I blame my brother.

Filed under: critical thinking — Jender @ 2:30 pm
Tags: ,

Apparently, those with sisters grow up to be happier than those with brothers.

“Sisters appear to encourage more open communication and cohesion in families. “However, brothers seemed to have the alternative effect.

So I guess Jender-Brother (or J-Bro, as I like to call him*) had an easy time thanks to my lovely influence. But it didn’t stop him from messing me up. Or maybe we canceled each other out– there I was, trying to encourage emotional expression, and there he was stamping it out at every turn! The article contains no reflection on families with only children, and gives no indication of whether those under discussion came from families with children all of one sex. Also little reflection on the pernicious effect it might have to tell parents or expectant parents that their boys can be expected to make family life less happy. Whee! Thanks(?) Jender-Mom, for sending that one on!

*I think it helps with the bonding. I’m like that.

 

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,681 other followers