Feminist Philosophers

News feminist philosophers can use

Boy Toys/Girl Toys May 17, 2010

Filed under: gender,gendered products — Jender @ 2:34 pm

From here. (Thanks, HG!)

 

12 Responses to “Boy Toys/Girl Toys”

  1. justanotherfemalephilosopher Says:

    I see the point being made here, and there’s something to it — but a doll can be a source of much creative thinking (it does more than just “be a doll”). My friends and I used to come up with some pretty elaborate stories and dialogue for our dolls. Not to mention the clothes we made or the furniture we built. So, give dolls and electronics to both boys and girls, I say.

  2. Jean Says:

    When I saw the headline, I thought you were going to talk about this unbelievable story–

    http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/16/fashion/16cougar.html?hpw

    Google refuses to advertise websites connecting older women with boytoys, but accepts ads for websites connecting older men with girltoys. Appalling (on general grounds, not because I’m looking for a boytoy–agh)!

  3. LaNeshe Says:

    lol, interesting point. Historically “boy toys” teach little boys to build and make things, and “girl toys” teach girls to be pretty, decorate, and be domestic.

  4. Carl Says:

    What about GI Joe? That’s pretty clearly just a doll for boys.

  5. Matt Says:

    What about GI Joe? That’s pretty clearly just a doll for boys.

    No way, man! That’s an “Action Figure”, totally different from a doll. At least that’s what me and my friends told ourselves.

  6. Kathryn Says:

    action figure
    Function: noun
    Definition: a doll, that we do not call a doll, so that boys can safely play with them without elevating girls who play with dolls to a level of play equality.

  7. Rachael Says:

    I think there are two closely related processes at work: one where the awesome engineering stuff is marketed toward boys (the cool toys become boys’ toys), and one where people adjust their opinions about the value of things like GI Joe upward, and their opinions about the value of things like dolls downward, for dubious gendered reasons (the boys’ toys become cool). I’m not always sure how to distinguish these processes.

    One of favorite girls’ toys is needlework–something about combination of engineering intelligence required to design and execute a pattern, combined with the soothing repetitive motions. It’s similar to lego, jigsaw puzzles, and origami in that way.

  8. [...] my daughters toys … which include some dolls, rockets, r/c planes and soldering kits. Coming up, … [...]

  9. i’m reminded of the toy inventors i know.
    two of them were once a husband and wife team.
    they wanted to make toys that could be equally enjoyed by boys and girls. long story short: in the 80′s it didn’t work.

  10. jj Says:

    Mike: the article you cite is from 1988; recent work provides serious challenges to it. See: http://feministphilosophers.wordpress.com/2009/10/12/another-theory-bites-the-dust/

  11. Mike Says:

    jj

    That’s interesting. But if there isn’t genetic aspect to the disparities — you have to wonder what’s causing the verbal disparity. http://prema2.iacm.forth.gr/docs/resources/CultureGenderMath.pdf


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 272 other followers